Tag: Change ringing

  • Is bell ringing a uniquely English thing?

    Is bell ringing a uniquely English thing?

    Bells are everywhere. Ringing them in strict permutations for three hours is another matter.

    Short answer: no, and yes.

    Bells are rung all over the world. Walk through almost any European town on a Sunday and you will hear them. But the particular thing English ringers do on a practice night, standing in a circle and pulling ropes in carefully worked-out sequences, is a very English invention. It has barely spread beyond the places England sent its vicars and its bellfounders.

    What makes the English version different

    English bells are hung for full-circle ringing. Each bell sits on a wheel, and the ringer swings it through a full circle, from mouth up to mouth up. That gives each ringer close control over exactly when the bell strikes, which means the order of the bells can be changed one stroke at a time.

    That is change ringing. You start in rounds, the bells sounding in turn down the scale, then swap the order according to a set of rules called a method. The ringers learn the rules rather than a long list of numbers, and a conductor calls variations so the same pattern can be extended without repeating itself.

    The maths is unforgiving. Five bells give you 120 possible orders. Seven give you 5,040. Twelve give you 479,001,600, which Britannica reckons would take about 40 years to ring.

    It started in the 17th century, perhaps a little earlier. The phrase “ring the changes” turns up in a sermon in 1614, and the Ancient Society of College Youths, founded in 1637, is still ringing today. The first book on the subject, Tintinnalogia, appeared in 1668. It was written by Richard Duckworth and published by Fabian Stedman, whose name is on the title page. Stedman then wrote Campanalogia (1677) himself, which set out much of the basis of modern method ringing. He is still known as the father of change ringing, and a method called Stedman carries his name.

    The first recorded true peal was rung at St Peter Mancroft, Norwich, on 2 May 1715: 5,040 changes of Plain Bob Triples. A peal today means at least 5,000 changes, non-stop, no row repeated, usually taking around three hours. The Central Council describes it as the ringer’s marathon.

    The Council explains it with a motorsport analogy, which I appreciated. All the ringers follow the same pattern but start from different places, like cars on the same circuit at staggered intervals. When the conductor calls a “bob”, some of them swap places with the car next to them. Unlike real racing, nobody is meant to get closer to anyone else.

    The numbers

    Dove’s Guide, the Central Council’s register of towers, currently lists about 7,100 rings of three or more bells hung for English-style full-circle ringing. About 6,660 of them are in England. That is roughly 94%.

    The rest are a short list, and you can trace most of it on a map of old Church of England links. Wales has about 230. Australia has 70, the United States 48, Ireland 39 and Scotland 23. New Zealand and South Africa have nine each and Canada eight. The Netherlands has two, and there are one-offs in Belgium, France, Spain, Kenya, India, Pakistan, Singapore and Zimbabwe.

    So it is not just English. It is overwhelmingly English.

    What everyone else does

    Most of Europe swings its bells rather than ringing them full circle. The bell swings back and forth and sounds as it goes, with no attempt to place each stroke in a precise order. Lovely, but not change ringing.

    The Low Countries went another way with the carillon. The bells hang still and are played from a keyboard of wooden batons and pedals, with wires pulling the clappers against the bells. That makes it an actual musical instrument, with melodies and harmony, played by one person.

    Spain has its own rich tradition of manual ringing, including bells turned through full rotations, which UNESCO added to its heritage list in 2022. But it is a local language of signals and festive peals, not permutations.

    The closest cousin is in northern Italy. The Veronese system (campane alla veronese) dates from 1776 at San Giorgio in Braida, Verona. Bells are rung full circle with a rope and wheel, and each ringer holds the bell mouth up with no stay to help them. On the maestro’s call they pull it through one complete turn for a single strike, then hold it up again. The result is tunes, scales and chords played from a score. Similar mechanics, very different idea. The English ring permutations; the Veronese play music.

    The Central Council’s own history admits nobody really knows why change ringing took root only in England. The Reformation, a booming Elizabethan economy and the Dutch preferring carillons are all plausible suspects.

    A footnote for pedants

    The study and art of bell ringing is campanology, from the Late Latin campana, a bell. Stedman spelt his book Campanalogia. The dictionary went with the o.

    And if you want the news, The Ringing World has been printed every week since 1911, which is the most English sentence in this piece.

    My day job involves a fair amount of permutations and process discipline, so I can see the appeal. Six people, a set of rules and three hours with no room for a wrong row is a pretty good description of a well-run month end.

    The rest of the world rings bells. England rings the changes.